3. Comparison Grid
          3.5. Output
 3.5.3. Sort 

Sort

Bibus EndNoteWeb (web based) RefWorks (web based) Procite EndNote Reference Manager
Sort Sort  Sort  Sort  Sort  Sort 

1 - Basic sort criterion for characters:
   1. operating system's tables
   2. program specific settings and/or tables
   3. user defined table (es. ä = ae)
   4. diacritics make difference (if yes, it is usually wrong: "é" is sorted after "e": Fewer, Robert comes before Fénelon, Marcel)

Bibus: Python system defined
4: yes
EW: unknown; 4: Diacritics do make a difference in printing bibliographies: incorrect, but not in export or browsing the database list RW: can select language sort option based on operating system's localization options; 4: no, Diacritics do not make difference: correct Pr: 1; 2 internal regional tables; 4: no Diacritics do not make difference: correct

Leading punctuation is always ignored. Apart from Dates and Call Number digits are still letters. 2 non-filing strings lists available see below Changing sort criterium / table, requires database rebuild; LC Call/Classification and Dewey numbers are taken into account and sorted before digits and letters; Dates are converted into an internal format and sorted consequently

En: 1: MS-Windows active table for output list. Leading blanks and punctuation marks are ignored for titles, other punctuation is taken into account; author sort can consider all the authors in the field or just the first surname; two non-filing leading text strings lists available (see below); 4: no Diacritics do not make difference which is correct; internal regional tables can be chosen to handle diacritics differently RM: 1; 2 internal regional tables; can also set "Character set sort " where letters with diacritics are sorted at the end; 4: yes Diacritics make difference

Leading punctuation and articles are never ignored. Digits are still mixed with letters apart from Dates and RN where they have numeric value

2 - Sort keys on different levels

Bibus : no EW: it depends on the selected bibliographic style, usually hidden to the user (unless he has access to EndNote desktop) RW: yes, up to 3 (prepared and not configurable) Pr: yes, 2 or 3 levels, 6 levels (each A/D) for custom sort order En: yes, 5 levels (each A/D) for db list sort; each output style has got its sort order based on 5 predefined and composite criteria + 1 custom (in which: 5 levels, each A/D) (+ 1 option to sort edited works after original works of the same author) RM: yes 3 levels (each one A/D) on any field

3 - How to sort for printing

Bibus : a) clic to sort the record list to be printed;
b) sorting references while formatting a manuscript: within any stule select the sort field (bibliography sequence, identifier, any field)
EW: it is embedded in the selected bibliographic style RW: sort the db (or a subset, i.e.: any folder or view list) before printing and sort specifications within the style will not be used; each citation style has got its sort orders for export, bibliographic list and in-text citations within manuscripts.
Cannot create user defined sort criteria
Pr: ready made options from pull down menu; citation styles have got their specifications that can be overwritten

En: records to be exported or printed in a subject bibliography or formatted in a manuscript will be sorted according to the chosen output style's specifications

RM: from the database reference list it uses the sort order of the selected list of records; for the manuscript bibliography list and in-text citations it uses the style's specifications that can also be altered on the fly from within the CWYW function (see Manuscript formatting)

4 - Can alter the sort value of a string (e.g.  ignore initial articles and punctuation marks  = non-filing strings)

Bibus : no EW: no RW: no Pr: only leading stopwords (2 lists : authors, generic)

Stopwords cannot be disactivated: must be emptied. Stopword in beginning position can be preserved if followed by hard space (Ctrl-Shift-space)

En: leading punctuation always excluded + leading non-filing text strings (2 lists: authors, titles)

Stopwords cannot be disactivated: must be emptied

RM: no, (leading stopwords not available: bad titles sort)

5 -  Other: varia

Bibus : EW: RW: Pr: Custom sort lets also choose between: empty fields first or last; all authors or only first; full name vs surname; full date vs year En: special provisions for anonymous works and for edited works optionally sorted after original works by the same author RM: can sort kw within the kw field

6.0  - Sort can produce headings above sorted records (so-called : "subject bibliography", i.e. indexed/headed report list)

Bibus : no EW: no RW: no Pr: yes, also headings only, without records (alphabetic sort) En: yes, also headings only, without records
a) alphabetic sort A/D, b) on the basis of occurrences (Term count) A/D
RM:  yes, also headings only, without records
a) alphabetic A/D sort, b) on the basis of occurrences (Term count) A/D

6.1  - Sort keys are another item from headings (i.e. sort on A, display B), so that they can match or be different

Bibus : n.a. EW: n.a. RW: n.a. Pr: no, they are just the same thing En: no, they are just the same thing RM: no, they are just the same thing

6.2  - Headings do not need to be displayed within records

Bibus :n.a. EW: n.a. RW: n.a. Pr: yes, they do not En: yes, they do not RM: yes, they do not

6.3  - More than one level of sort key as headings

Bibus : n.a. EW: n.a. RW: n.a. Pr: no, only one, though headings can come from n fields at once (e.g. mixed sorting by subject and classes) En: no, only one, though headings can come from n fields at once (e.g. mixed sorting by subject and classification numbers) RM: no, only one, though headings can come from n fields at once (e.g. mixed sorting by subject and classification numbers)

6.4  - Sort of records under the same sort key

Bibus : n.a. EW: n.a. RW: n.a. Pr: ruled by the print sort order En: ruled by the print sort order belonging to each output style: can be altered on the fly RM: uses the database general sort order

6.5 -  Records are referenced more than once by different sort headings

Bibus : n.a. EW: n.a. RW: n.a. Pr: yes, records are fully printed each time (no "light indexes" with cross references) En: yes, records are fully printed each time (no "light indexes" with cross references) RM: yes, records are fully printed each time (no "light indexes" with cross references)

6.6 -   Can produce indexes referencing records in the database by a short element (e.g. RN)

Bibus : n.a. EW: n.a. RW: n.a. Pr: yes En: yes RM: yes
Bibus EndNoteWeb (web based) RefWorks (web based) Procite EndNote Reference Manager
Sort Sort  Sort  Sort  Sort  Sort 
Keywords:  Diacritics (sorting) ; Headed list ; Non-filing strings ; Sort ; Subject bibliography

Table of contents  | Index